Back To Deductive & Inductive Symposium Page

Reviewer 1’s Comments

Although Eadie presents an immersive listening experience, there is no discussion of inductive or deductive processes within the arts. The description does not serve to elucidate either, as it only mentions memory and listening within improvisation. If a proposition for how the piece could be listened to through a theme related to the conference, or the process of its creation more clearly explained relevant to the call out, it could better be justified for inclusion. Furthermore, memory, improvisation, and listening are merely fields. These topics need to be critically discussed in relation to the artistic work such that this can be understood as artistic research.

Reviewer 2’s Comments

This work, with its reference to memory and improvisation, touches on ideas of inductive and deductive but is not explicit to the theme. However, with a brief revision by the author about how the compositional process more explicitly engages with these ideas I think this is a good selection. If I could suggest a thought, I think there is something to be had about thinking of the voices and the pitch convergence as a type of musical crossing where inductive and deductive collide, explode, blend, and influence each other. Esthetically this is lovely, and the production quality is quite nice. As a conductor I love this sound!

SZT’s Question

This question goes right to the heart of my thoughts about the cognitive approaches to deduction and induction. When you talk about memory and listening in your exegesis, do you mean the momentary musical memory of phrase to phrase similarity and difference (the inductive learning process) or the bigger deductive metaphor that takes one a more Proustian scale?

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Reviewer 3
Reviewer 3
4 months ago

There is potential for greater discussion on how the compositional process (using improvisation and memory) relates to the theme of the symposium. A video submission was always going to struggle to reveal that, without resorting to being more verbose – one of the many challenges of validating performance research. A sentence or two about how it relates to inductive or deductive processes of constructing the piece might help consolidate this submission.